Ban Indie Bookstores Before You Ban Amazon

Cat hates your opinion of wanting to ban AmazonHas this happened to you? You’re chatting about your book on Amazon and they react to the word “Amazon” as though you mentioned the Devil. They want to ban Amazon. Well I’d rather ban indie bookstores before banning Amazon.

I’ve heard that people hate how Amazon is putting local bookstores out of business. On the other hand, I’ve also heard an author say that if local bookstores want to compete with Amazon, they should start being friendly to the authors, not just the customers. What are your thoughts? Why do people hate Amazon so much? What do you say to those people?

I decided to find out once and for all why people hate Amazon so much. After doing a tree-friendly (aka online) search for the horrible truth about Amazon, I was able to narrow the issues down. Here are the three top myths why you should avoid making your books available on Amazon.


Myth #1

Amazon is destroying the reading culture – At indie bookstores there are author readings, places to lounge and read on a cold day, and friendly interactions with the booksellers. If all the indie bookstores close, we will have lost that entire reading culture.

And if that were true, I’d agree. But Amazon isn’t destroying any reading culture. If nothing else, people are buying more books than ever because of Amazon’s low prices. When someone has a budget of, say, $20 a month to spend on books, they can buy up to twenty ebooks on Amazon, compared to only two or three paperbacks in bookstores. If we define the reading culture as interacting with booksellers and attending author readings, then we’re missing the most important part of what our reading culture is: reading books. Amazon is not destroying any reading culture.


Myth #2

Amazon is stealing customers – Selling books is an indie bookstore’s bread and butter. If Amazon keeps selling their books at lower prices than indie bookstores, no one will buy books from bookstores anymore. How are indie bookstores expected to compete? They can’t lower their prices because they have all sorts of costs to cover just to break even.

But the problem with this argument is that indie bookstores have a clientele Amazon will never have. The typical patron of the bookstore is someone who likes to browse through the books. If they see something that looks good, they can buy it and have the physical book in their hands right away. When it comes to Amazon, I personally have never gone to their website just to browse through their books. I only go when I have a specific book in mind. Maybe after I put the book in the shopping cart, I look at others, but I never go to Amazon with the expressed purpose of browsing through all their books. I don’t know anyone who does.

And Amazon will likely never be able to hand the physical copy of the book to the buyer immediately. Either the customer has to wait for the book to come in the mail, or they have to get a downloadable version of the book. Anyone who enjoys reading downloadable books is not an indie bookstore’s clientele, anyhow, so Amazon is not stealing them. Yes, maybe those individuals were once people who read physical books, but as technology changes, the definition of who the target market also changes.

Okay, so Amazon may have the best prices. Indie bookstores should then realize that their clientele no longer includes bargain hunters. They can work more towards presenting their store as a classy establishment for those interested in indulging themselves. The whole “We’re expensive, but you’re worth it” attitude. I’ve seen “Gourmet Peanuts” that cost three times as much as Planters. And people actually buy that stuff! They like the feeling of luxury. I’ve also seen plenty of specialized indie bookstores. Jewish bookstores, LGBT bookstores, those are the ones that know their clientele well. The store becomes not just a place to to buy books, but a place to meet like-minded people in person. As long as indie-bookstores understand who their current market is, they’ll see that their clientele are for the most part not the same people as those who buy books from Amazon.


Myth #3

Amazon doesn’t support local authors – Indie bookstores are capable of helping out authors by giving them exposure via author readings. Amazon has never given authors the opportunity to hold readings, even online readings.

While that’s true, I have a personal beef with indie bookstores. Financially, they are so hard-up for income that the local bookstores I’ve tried to get my book placed in have a consignment system that ultimately has me pay to get in their bookstores. The percentage they offer me is less than the price it costs me to make the book. Amazon has been the best thing for my book sales.

For my physical book, I’ve set it up so that they take only 20% of the retail price for the physical book. It costs 60% of the retail price to make the book (because it’s print-on-demand; bulk printing is much cheaper but then you have to store all the boxes of books somewhere). That leaves me with 20% of the sale. Most local bookstores require 40%-60% of the retail price. If local bookstores really want to help local authors, they need to allow the author to profit from the sale.

Amazon has also been great at helping my book be discovered and sold. The Torah Codes (the ebook version) has been listed in the top twenty bestselling Jewish fiction books since December, 2011. Additionally, my book is associated with others via Amazon’s “Customers who bought this item also bought” feature, and there are many customer reviews so people can see if my book is something they’d be interested in reading. Indie bookstores don’t have super-niched genre-specific bestselling lists, they don’t have a way to let their shoppers know that anyone who enjoyed reading The Da Vinci Code would also like The Torah Codes, and since the bookseller is likely not someone who has read my book, I doubt she’d ever be able to recommend it.

I honestly don’t see what’s wrong with Amazon. They’re more a threat to companies like Best Buy than to indie bookstores. For all those people who love the experience of feeling luxurious, meeting like-minded readers in person, attending author readings, chatting with the booksellers, and lounging with a good book in a comfortable store — and there are many of such people — Amazon is not tailored for those readers and those readers will always choose the indie bookstore. As long as the indie bookstores are clear on who their market is, they will always be in business. And the way Amazon helps authors so much, I’d sooner ban indie bookstores than ban Amazon.

You now have my permission to rant.


Book marketing mentor, Ezra Barany is the author of the award-winning bestseller, The Torah Codes. Contact Ezra now to begin the conversation on how he can help you. You can connect with Ezra via FacebookTwitter, contact him through this blog, or by email: EZRA at THETORAHCODES dot COM.

You may also like...

  • Terri Bruce says:

    There’s no way I’m the first commenter on this post?!

    I value all my fingers and toes too much to enter into this debate :p, so I’ll just say interesting article – lots to think about and some really good points!

  • As an Indie author I rely on Amazon as my primary sales channel but would love to have more of a bookstore presence. I approached my local Indie bookstore (where I have been a customer for years) and offered them a free book to consider. I also offered to host a reading event which would have generated definite sales and brought in customers for other books. I’d been steering people who want a paper copy of my book to them as well (even though I make more on Amazon). The bookstore didn’t even get back to me.

    I think a lot of Indie bookstores are going about this the wrong way – rather than shunning Indie authors, they need to embrace the change going on in the new publishing world and become part of it. That way they can still offer their customers something new and different. Why else would people want to spend 20% more for books?


  • Nina says:

    “Anyone who enjoys reading downloadable books is not an indie bookstore’s clientele, anyhow, so Amazon is not stealing them.”

    I have to disagree with this statement, as I very much love my local indie bookstore, and go there to hang out, looking at books etc, at least once a week. Still I now buy most of my books from Amazon for my Kindle, because they are that much cheaper, meaning I can afford more books. I’m sure I can’t be the only person out there who loves indie bookstores but also enjoys reading downloadable books:)

  • Peter Dudley says:

    I was told not so long ago by an independent bookseller in San Francisco that while they’d love to have me attend a YA night they were having, my self-published YA book was not welcome because I published it through Amazon, and “Amazon is against everything we stand for.” (I blogged this, link here for the curious and super-bored: )

    I understand that they don’t like the KDP Select exclusivity clause for ebooks. And I understand that there are people who browse their store and then go buy a cheaper print copy from Amazon. I understand that Amazon is the dart-board target for many changes going on in reading and publishing. They aren’t Amazon fans. I get it.

    But they’re having a YA night. I’m a local author with a well received YA book that their clientele might enjoy. And they turn it away, unseen.

    What, exactly, do they “stand for?”

    Also, I think you’re right about the upscale/experience aspect of indie bookstores. That’s their differentiator, and the successful ones will be those that can monetize the experience, not just the book purchase.

  • Ezra Barany says:

    Max, I couldn’t have said it better myself. “A lot of Indie bookstores are going about this the wrong way – rather than shunning Indie authors, they need to embrace the change going on in the new publishing world and become part of it.” Well said!

    Nina, you’re the only one in the world who likes both indie bookstores and reading downloadable books. Just kidding. Thanks for making a good point. I’m sure there are a lot of us out there. I’d go to the indie bookstores more often, but then I’d buy some books and can’t eat for a week.

    Peter, I get so frustrated when I hear stories like yours of how bookstores are treating indie authors. It’s like they’re on the Titanic sinking and the best way they can come up with saving themselves is by picketing icebergs. *Nice kittens, by the way.

  • Peter (who commented above) sent me. I like this post a lot. Of course the talk of banning is just tongue-in-cheek, but if one or the other had to go, as both a reader and an author I would want to keep Amazon. They give us—readers and authors alike—what we want.

    You know what I would do if I owned an indie bookstore? Place a couple of terminals along a wall, like a mini internet cafe, with a sign above them that said, “If you prefer to buy from Amazon, have a seat, log in. If you need help finding a book on Amazon, or opening an account, our staff will be happy to assist.”

    I think customers would buy more books if they thought the store was serving them, rather than fighting competitors.

  • I must thank you for the efforts you’ve put in penning this site. I’m hoping to see the same high-grade content from
    you later on as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged
    me to get my own, personal blog now 😉

  • From my experience, indie bookstores, as well as big name bookstores fall short in supporting authors, unless they are bestsellers. Also, beware if you’re a self-publisher and accept returns, which is usually a requirement for getting into big name stores, because the store will over-order and you’re stuck with the bill, plus $2 more if you want your book back to try and sell it somewhere else.

    Morgan Mandel

  • Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Amazon verses Indie bookstores. I had heard similar things about, “Oh no don’t buy from Amazon they are putting the Indie stores out of business.” I like Indie stores myself but I mostly buy from either Amazon or used bookstores when I am wanting to browse and touch the books. Occasionally I will go to the big chains to browse the discount section to see if I can find a good bargain. I actually prefer to touch books myself but I understand that the times are changing. Mostly I go where the discounts are because that is what I can afford for my book habit.

    I am working on an MS and have decided to go the self-publishing route myself. I like that I can have control of it and I am willing to do the work that is necessary to promote it. I love that I can go straight to Amazon through CreateSpace to accomplish that.

    Something I do want to share, a writer friend of mine posted this for those self publishing writers that would like to get into local bookstores. I found it quite helpful. She has a friend that owns an Indie bookstore and she asked them their advice for indie authors on how to get their books in the door.


  • Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after browsing through a few of the posts I realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely pleased I found it and I’ll be bookmarking it and checking back often!

  • Paymundo says:

    Next time I read a blog, Hopefully it doesn’t fail me as much as this one. After all, Yes, it was my choice to read through, nonetheless I actually believed you would have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you weren’t too busy searching for attention.

  • Wonderful article! We are linking to this particularly great content on our site. Keep up the great writing.

  • Obrączki says:

    Pretty split of content. I merely stumbled upon your website and in taking office first city to assert that I get in point of fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing to your augment and equal I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  • Mokume Gane says:

    Pretty! This has been an incredibly brilliant post. Show appreciation you for providing this information.

  • thanks says:

    I have been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts in this sort of space . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this site. Studying this info So i am happy to exhibit that I’ve an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed. I most no doubt will make certain to do not omit this site and provides it a glance regularly.

  • pharm says:

    Hands down, Apple’s app store wins almost a mile. It’s a colossal safe conduct of all sorts of apps vs a unreservedly deplorable choice of a troublemaker pro Zune. Microsoft has plans, remarkably in the area of games, but I’m not tried I’d sine qua non to risk on the following if this viewpoint is formidable to you. The iPod is a much safer prime in that case.

  • Lee says:

    Thank you for all your unbreakable job on behalf of keeping the site by crown of mind!

  • Eliseo says:

    My brother optional I’d like this website. He was entirely decent. This suggest in fact made my day. You cannot imagine only how a lot calculate I had exhausted representing this information! Thanks!

  • I solve not still be aware of how I defunct awake at this juncture, except I idea this post was sunny. I accomplish not know who you are but without doubt you’re going to a well-known blogger if you are not before now Cheers!

  • Filiberto says:

    I in adding to my pals were originate to ensue analyzing the trivial suggestion originate by your website then facing elongated residential a terrible hunch I had not articulated respect to the web blog owner for those secrets. Each and every one the guys are actually representing this reason happy to see them and have in prompt undeniably been enjoying them. We appreciate you getting undeniably considerate and next for deciding by this classify of clear subject areas mainly ancestors are especially in need to ensue discerning of. Our straightforward apologies for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.

  • Ross says:

    That is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I have joined your feed and sit up for in quest of extra of your magnificent post. Additionally, I’ve shared your website in my social networks!

  • >